On-again-off-again-on-again (does it really matter anymore?) couple Justin Bieber and Selena Gomez were recently seen together having a romantic dinner, prompting Jelena fangirls everywhere to start planning their future wedding and photoshopping what their babies might look like.

A source told Us Weekly that the couple looked "happy and in love” as they ate around 1 a.m. at Marble Lane in New York City on Nov. 28.

The restaurant-goer continued to ogle the pair enough to ruin their alone time and commented that they were "giggling, like nothing ever happened.”

"When it came time to leave, Justin held her hand and looked very protective of her. It was sweet," said another witness.

What were all these people doing in a restaurant at 1 a.m. on a Tuesday night? We suppose that's why they had so much free time to ponder the relationship status of the Biebs and his lady love, who announced their short-lived split several weeks ago.

Now that the current drama has passed, we can continue our Selena and Justin-free lives. Until the next time they're seen out in public together, of course. (Hey kids, how about staying in and ordering pizza for a change?)